Key Lime Pie


In stock

Unit price
    Pick your delivery date

    Choose from TUE to SAT*

    Order by 3 PM EST

    To get it delivered tomorrow

    Earn up to 895 Sand Dollars.

    For each of this product

    SKU: KPIE Category:

    Looking for the perfect dessert to finish off a delightful seafood dinner? An honest to goodness key lime pie is in order. 

    A tart and tangy taste of the tropics made with authentic Key West key lime juice. Made locally by The Ever So Humble Pie Shop. Voted Best Pie Company in Massachusetts, 2023. 

    The folks from Florida will be jealous with this Key Lime Pie!

    It is made with 1% Low-fat, farm fresh milk from Crescent Ridge Dairy and are topped with 100% REAL Whipped Cream! NO artificial colors, flavors or preservatives and absolutely NO hydrogenated oils or trans fat!

    This five inch key lime pie is perfect for small families or served as individual desserts. (And although they’re big enough to serve two, most folks eat the whole thing themselves!)

    Sorry Not Shipped By Itself. Must be added to a fresh seafood or Lobster order

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 15 reviews
    Jean (Cumming, GA)
    Key Lime Pie

    We really enjoyed the Key Lime Pie. Will be ordering it again!

    Todd Van Gough (Smyrna, GA)

    Great pie , could be more limey, still very good!!

    Bryan Reinhart (Bloomingdale, NJ)

    Loved the lobster and pie. Had lobster rolls for lunch for 2 weeks!

    Lynn C. (Gig Harbor, WA)
    Gift item

    Sent clam chowder and lemon pies. My dad loved the items.

    Colleen (Lansdale, PA)
    Awesome dessert

    Bought an extra pie to go along with dinner for my dads birthday. He absolutely loved the pie and said it was worth the extra money

    Your personal data will be used to support your experience throughout this website, to manage access to your account, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.