The Complete History of Lobster: From Ancient Origins to Global Luxury

How Lobster Became a Luxury Food: The Complete Story

History of Lobster: From Ancient Origins to Luxury
Pen-and-ink timeline of lobster’s rise—from ancient Egypt and Roman feasts to Colonial “poor-man’s food,” New York’s Lobster Palaces, and modern conservation.

The history of lobster spans millions of years, transforming from prehistoric sustenance to luxury cuisine. This lobster chronicle reveals how one crustacean became a global culinary icon.

The History of Lobster

From “poor-man’s food” to premium luxury — an illustrated timeline

Early Abundance / Disdain Transformation Luxury Status
c. 1473–1458 BCE · Ancient Egyptian Depictions Read more

Reliefs at Queen Hatshepsut’s temple show Red Sea crustaceans as prized goods within royal expeditions and ritual art.

Royal Delicacy
100–700 CE · Roman & Moche Reverence Read more

From elaborate recipes in De Re Coquinaria to Moche lobster effigy pottery, lobsters hold cultural and culinary prestige.

Sacred & Luxury
1500s–1600s · European Elite Status Read more

Lobster appears frequently on royal tables and in Dutch still-life paintings as a symbol of wealth and temptation.

Royal Food
1605–1700s · Colonial America: Abundance & Disdain Read more

Mass strandings fed prisoners, servants, and livestock; shells around homes were once seen as “signs of poverty.”

Poverty Food
1700s–early 1800s · Servant & Prisoner Food Read more

Lobsters were fertilizer and bait; some specimens exceeded 20 lbs. Reputation lagged despite ubiquity.

Low-Status Fare
1840s–1860s · Transportation Revolution Read more

Railroads and early canneries (first in Maine, 1840s) move lobster to urban markets; coastal tourism boosts demand.

Rising Status
1880s–1910s · Urban Luxury Emergence Read more

New York’s glittering “Lobster Palaces” help cement lobster as a high-society delicacy.

City Delicacy
1920s–Present · Modern Global Icon Read more

From Gatsby-era glamour to Dalí’s surrealism, lobster evolves into a multi-billion-dollar luxury industry.

Global Luxury
2000s–2025 · Premium Global Commodity Read more

E-commerce and overnight logistics bring Maine lobster shore-to-door™ worldwide; sustainability remains a key focus.

Ultimate Treasure

Ancient Lobster History: From 250 Million Years Ago to Egyptian Queens

Lobster heritage dates back 250 million years, when spiny and slipper lobsters first diverged during the Permian period. Clawed lobsters (Nephropidae family) emerged during the Lower Cretaceous (~133-140 million years ago), with the Homarus genus appearing around 100 million years ago.

Egyptian Queen Hatshepsut's temple Red Sea lobsters

The earliest chapter of human lobster history dates back over 11,000 years, as evidenced by lobster remains found in North American shell middens. Ancient civilizations embraced these creatures—Egyptian Queen Hatshepsut’s temple (c. 1473-1458 BCE) depicted Red Sea lobsters, while Aristotle described them around 384-322 BCE in the History of Animals. Roman cookbook De Re Coquinaria featured elaborate lobster recipes, establishing a luxury status that continues today with modern lobster cooking techniques.

Medieval to Renaissance Lobster Heritage

Olaus Magnus Giant Lobsters

King Henry VIII regularly enjoyed lobster feasts, while medical texts credited therapeutic properties, including aphrodisiac qualities—beliefs that influenced traditional lobster preparation methods still used today(noted by Tobias Venner, c. 1620).In 1555, Olaus Magnus depicted giant sea lobsters in exploration literature, describing 12-foot monsters that could snatch sailors from ships. Dutch Golden Age painters, such as Jan Davidsz de Heem, included lobsters in their lavish still-life paintings as symbols of wealth and earthly temptation. Merchants profitably traded live Norwegian lobsters from around 1650.

Fascinating fact: A Dutch shipwreck carrying Norwegian lobsters created the genetically isolated lobster population still found in the Netherlands’ Oosterschelde estuary today

In his famous diary, Samuel Pepys recorded a sophisticated London dinner party from 1663 that featured four lobsters among other refined dishes. European lobster (H. gammarus) maintained luxury status while its American cousin (H. americanus) was scorned.

Why Colonial Americans Hated Lobster: The ‘Poor Man’s Food’ Era

Why was lobster considered poor man’s food in Colonial America?

Lobster was considered “poor man’s food” in Colonial America due to its overwhelming abundance and accessibility. Key reasons include:

  • Massive abundance – Lobsters washed ashore in 2-foot piles after storms
  • Social stigma – Called “cockroach of the sea” and associated with poverty
  • Fed to lower classes – Given to prisoners, servants, and indentured workers
  • Used as waste – Served as fertilizer, fishing bait, and livestock feed
  • Size difference – Colonial lobsters were often 20+ pounds (vs 1-2 pounds today)

The abundance was so extreme that lobster shells around a house were “looked upon as signs of poverty and degradation.”

European settlers encountered an overwhelming abundance of American lobsters, dramatically altering the history of lobsters. This abundance created disdain—colonists deemed it “poverty food” or the “cockroach of the sea.” William Wood (1634) documented this contempt. Lobsters fed servants, prisoners, and livestock, contrasting sharply with European reverence.

The Price Reality:

The numbers tell the story: canned lobster in the 1850s cost around 11 cents per pound, while Boston baked beans cost 53 cents. Lobster was literally five times cheaper than beans—reflecting the pure economics of overwhelming supply and zero demand.

Today’s premium pricing represents one of history’s most dramatic commodity transformations—see the complete price evolution data from pennies to luxury rates.

William Wood Depicted Lobster as Poverty Food

Why Colonists Fed Lobster to Prisoners and Servants

1605: First recorded European lobster catch in Maine by Captain Weymouth’s expedition

17th-18th Century: American colonists viewed lobster as “poverty food.”

  • Washed ashore in 2-foot piles after storms
  • Fed to prisoners, servants, and livestock
  • Used as fertilizer and fishing bait
  • Called “cockroach of the sea” and “poor man’s chicken.”
  • Lobster shells around a house were “looked upon as signs of poverty and degradation.”
  • Some historic American lobsters weighed 20+ pounds (compared to 1-2 pounds today)—learn more about lobster size identification.

Myth: Stories of servant contracts limiting lobster meals to three times per week (no historical evidence found despite extensive research)

Late 1800s: Railroads expanded distribution; coastal tourism introduced urbanites to fresh lobster

How Lobster Became Expensive: The 1800s Transformation from Trash to Treasure

When did lobster become expensive in America?

Lobster became expensive in America during the 1840s-1860s due to three key developments:

  • Railroad expansion (1840s) – Enabled transportation to inland cities where lobster was unknown
  • Canning technology (1842) – First Maine lobster cannery made preservation possible
  • Tourism boom (1850s-1860s) – Wealthy visitors to New England developed a taste for fresh lobster

By the 1850s, New York’s “Lobster Palaces” were serving lobster as a luxury item to high-society diners.

Perhaps no period in the history of lobster is more dramatic than its 19th-century metamorphosis from despised “poverty food” to a coveted luxury item in America. “Smack boats” with circulating seawater enabled live transport to cities. The 1840s canning boom (first Maine cannery, 1842) made lobster accessible nationwide but led to severe overfishing. Railroad expansion opened up inland markets, while wealthy New England tourists developed a taste for fresh, locally prepared foods.

Size decline: In 1860, 4-5 pound lobsters were considered “small” for canning; by the 1880s, canneries processed half-pound lobsters

The Economics Shift:

Urban diners, unfamiliar with coastal stigma, judged lobster purely on taste—and paid accordingly. This created the first real market for what had been worthless. When the canning boom led to overfishing, it paradoxically proved lobster’s commercial value.

See how these early price changes shaped today’s market.

Lobster Palaces New York

By the 1850s and 1860s, lobster had become a staple on the menus of prestigious urban establishments. New York’s “Lobster Palaces” solidified lobster’s status as a luxury item, pioneering restaurant-style lobster cooking that influenced home cooking methods. This luxury status is reflected in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby (1922).

The Price Premium Era:

Manhattan’s Lobster Palaces could charge premium prices because wealthy diners had no association with lobster’s humble past. By the 1920s, lobster reached its first price peak—then crashed during the Great Depression, proving its new status as a luxury commodity.

Discover how these boom-bust cycles continue today.

Lobster Conservation History: Science and Fishing Regulations

The lobster chronicle includes important scientific milestones. Thomas Say formally described Homarus americanus in 1817 (Henri Milne-Edwards assigned the current name in 1837). Francis Hobart Herrick’s 1895 monograph, “The American Lobster,” provided crucial biological insights, advocating for the protection of female lobsters during their reproductive period.

Early regulations emerged from concerns about depletion: Maine’s 1874 minimum size law (10.5 inches) and the 1872 ban on harvesting egg-bearing females effectively ended the canning industry by 1885.

Important Lobster Research Discoveries (1770-1895)

  • 1770: Joseph Banks documented Māori lobster fishing techniques in New Zealand—diving for lobsters by hand in shallow waters
  • 1817: Thomas Say formally classified the American lobster as a distinct species
  • 1837: Henri Milne-Edwards assigned the name Homarus americanus
  • 1895: Francis Hobart Herrick’s revolutionary study challenged fishing industry assumptions
    • Key discovery: Large female lobsters produce exponentially more eggs than smaller ones
    • Warning ignored: Argued against harvesting the largest, most fertile females
    • Ahead of his time: Advocated for maximum size limits and closed areas (ideas not adopted until decades later)

How Big Were Lobsters in Colonial Times?

How big were lobsters in colonial times?

Colonial lobsters were massive compared to today’s standards:

  • Colonial era (1600s-1700s): Often 20+ pounds, with some specimens reaching 44 pounds
  • 1860 canning era: 4-5 pound lobsters considered “small” for commercial processing
  • 1880s decline: Canneries processing half-pound juveniles due to overfishing
  • Today: Average market size is just 1-2 pounds

The dramatic size reduction resulted from overfishing the largest, most fertile female lobsters for centuries. As Francis Hobart Herrick warned in 1895, large females produce exponentially more eggs than smaller ones, but the fishing industry ignored this advice for decades.

20th Century Lobster Industry: Technology Revolution and Modern Challenges

Twentieth-century lobster development included technological advances—such as gasoline/diesel engines, improved boat designs, hydraulic trap haulers (introduced in the 1970s), wire traps, GPS, and sonar —which increased efficiency but also intensified fishing pressure.

Post-War Price Growth:

Technology advances paralleled steady price increases—from under $1 per pound in 1950 to over $12 by 2016. The industry learned to adapt through various economic cycles, building resilience for modern challenges.

View the complete 1950-2016 price data.

Environmental disasters like the 1996 North Cape oil spill (killing 9 million lobsters) highlighted industry vulnerability. The Western Australian Rock Lobster Fishery achieved the first Marine Stewardship Council certification (March 2000). The U.S. designated National Lobster Day as September 25th in 2015.

Lobster in Popular Culture: From Salvador Dalí to The Simpsons (1930s-Today)

How Lobster Became a Cultural Symbol in America

  • 1938: Salvador Dalí’s surrealist “Lobster Telephone” placed a lobster in high art—the crustacean positioned over the phone’s mouthpiece symbolized desire and unconscious sexuality
  • 1980s: Maine lobster became state’s economic cornerstone ($2+ billion regional impact today)
  • 1998: Homer Simpson’s “Pinchy” episode in The Simpsons—Homer adopts a lobster as a pet, accidentally cooks it, then tearfully devours it
  • 2015: U.S. Senate designated September 25th as National Lobster Day
Salvador Dalí's surrealist Lobster Telephone

Modern Lobster Industry Challenges: Climate Change and Whale Protection

Recent lobster history reveals both triumphs and challenges. Maine’s peak harvest reached 132.6 million pounds in 2016, but multiple pressures emerged: 2019 bait shortages, COVID-19 disruptions (requiring shifts to retail/direct sales), and climate change threats as the Gulf of Maine warms rapidly.

The most significant current challenge involves protecting the endangered North Atlantic right whales; new federal regulations mandate a 98% reduction in the risk of entanglement by fishing gear by 2030. Maine’s 2023 harvest dropped to 93.8 million pounds (the lowest since 2009), though higher prices maintained industry value.

Today’s Lobster Industry Problems: COVID, Climate, and Regulations

How Climate Change Affects Lobster Prices:

Today’s challenges echo past patterns—the Great Depression caused price drops similar to COVID-19 disruptions, but the industry adapted. Climate change represents something new: unlike past economic cycles, warming oceans create fundamental habitat shifts.

Compare historical vs. modern price volatility.

COVID-19 Adaptation Success: Industry demonstrated remarkable resilience

  • Restaurant closures threatened catastrophe
  • Pivot strategy: Shifted to retail/online direct-to-consumer sales
  • Result: 87% surge in retail lobster demand
  • Developed new home-cooking products and delivery systems

Climate Change Reality: Gulf of Maine warming at an accelerated rate

  • Paradox: Warmer waters currently benefit Maine lobster (expanded habitat, faster growth)
  • Future threat: Continued warming may cause population collapse like that of Southern New England
  • Migration pattern: Lobster populations are visibly shifting northward to Canadian waters
  • Ocean acidification warning: May affect shell development by 2050 under high emissions scenarios

Whale Protection Crisis: Strictest regulations in fishery history

  • Mandate: 98% reduction in North Atlantic right whale entanglement risk by 2030
  • Industry disruption: Modified trap placement, weaker “breakaway” ropes, seasonal closures of prime fishing areas
  • Innovation pressure: Research into “ropeless” or “on-demand” fishing gear to eliminate vertical buoy lines
  • Economic impact: Significant costs for gear modification and lost fishing time

Lobster History: Most Asked FAQ

Why was lobster once considered poor man’s food?

In colonial New England, lobsters were so abundant they washed ashore in piles. Cheap and easy to gather, they were fed to prisoners, servants, and even livestock, earning the nickname “cockroach of the sea.

When did lobster become a luxury in America?

By the late 1800s, railroads, canning, and “smack boats” made lobster widely available. Wealthy tourists and upscale New York “Lobster Palaces” transformed it from a humble food into a luxury delicacy.

Why Was Lobster Once Fed to Prisoners?

Colonial Americans considered lobster “poverty food” because it was so abundant it washed ashore in 2-foot piles after storms. They routinely fed it to prisoners, apprentices, and slaves because it was dirt-cheap and viewed as the “cockroach of the sea.

How Did Railroads Change the Lobster Industry?

Railroad expansion allowed inland wealthy diners to try fresh lobster for the first time. These customers had no negative preconceptions and appreciated the taste, creating new demand that drove up prices and established lobster’s luxury status.

What Makes Maine Lobster So Expensive Today?

Climate change forces lobsters into deeper waters, increasing fishing costs. Maine’s catch dropped from 132.6 million pounds (2016) to 93.7 million pounds (2023), reducing supply while demand stays high. Learn more about finding the best lobster prices and what size lobster to buy.

How Does Climate Change Affect Lobster Populations?

The Gulf of Maine is warming faster than 99% of oceans, forcing lobsters north into deeper waters. Southern New England’s lobster industry collapsed while Maine’s initially boomed with 219% increased landings (1994-2014). However, warmer waters attract predators and make shell formation harder.

How Big Were Lobsters in Colonial Times?

Historic lobsters weighed 20+ pounds versus today’s 1-2 pounds. In 1860, 4-5 pound lobsters were considered “small,” but by 1880, canneries processed half-pound lobsters. The largest recorded lobster weighed 44 pounds (Nova Scotia, 1988). See our guide on what size lobster to buy today.

Did Servants Really Protest Being Fed Too Much Lobster?

This is a myth. Food historian Sandy Oliver found no evidence of servants protesting or contracts limiting lobster meals. The story appeared in the 1900s when lobsters were scarcer to emphasize how abundant they once were.

Why Are Maine Lobsters Different from Other Lobsters?

Maine lobsters are cold-water lobsters with claws, producing sweeter, more tender meat. Warm-water lobsters lack claws and are sold as tails. Cold waters allow lobsters to grow more slowly, resulting in a better flavor. Learn more in our Lobster 101 guide about sustainable lobster sourcing.

Conclusion

Lobster’s transformation from abundant “poor man’s protein” to luxury symbol represents one of history’s most dramatic culinary reversals. Once fed to prisoners and used as fertilizer, this 100-million-year-old survivor became a coveted delicacy through clever marketing and improved transportation.

Today, the species faces its ultimate test: surviving climate change, overfishing, and warming oceans while meeting global demand for its resources. Modern conservation efforts now balance economic pressures with sustainable harvesting practices.

Companies like LobsterAnywhere.com represent the latest chapter in this evolution, pioneering online delivery systems that bring fresh Maine lobster directly to consumers nationwide. As digital commerce transforms seafood distribution, these platforms help sustain coastal fishing communities while making premium lobster accessible beyond traditional geographic boundaries.

The lobster’s journey from the ocean floor to overnight delivery reflects humanity’s complex relationship with marine resources—one that continues to evolve through technology, conservation science, and our enduring appetite for this remarkable crustacean.

References:

Add your comment

What are your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

A link to set a new password will be sent to your email address.

Your personal data will be used to support your experience throughout this website, to manage access to your account, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.