Maine lobster starts around $5.75 a pound on the dock, and this is the price that has existed in the range from $3.00 to $5.85 since about 2010. The price you see at stores, restaurants, and online is depending on how many intermediaries it passes through until it reaches your plate.
The cost increases each time it gets passed between the holding tanks, trucking companies, and distributors, then there are labor costs when it comes to cooking and preparation. The more of these you remove, the cheaper the price of lobster is per pound and in general.
If you buy direct from the dock and drive it back home yourself, you get the best price. By shopping with an online retailer that goes from dock to your door, you get the next best price. If the online store is a large seafood seller that has northwestern fish like salmon, crab from the Caribbean, mid-Atlantic and gulf oysters, and classic Maine lobsters, chances are the lobsters go to the distributor and their warehouse, not directly to your door and you pay more per pound for lobster and other seafood.

Then comes the outside factors that change the price of lobster including:
- Lobster season where they are closer to shore, the traps fill more thoroughly, and less fuel is used to get to the fishing grounds.
- Fuel costs impact the price for shipping as live lobsters must stay alive during transport.
- Lobsters that died more than 24 hours prior to cooking, or that died and were not stored at proper temperatures are not safe to eat.
- Consumer demand changes the price of lobster. When there is more demand, the prices go up as all Maine lobster and Caribbean spiny lobster in the USA is wild caught, and the price is dependent on the seasonal supply.

Now that you know why lobster meat changes at each place, and can cost more, here’s some tips to help you save on lobster meat on the per pound pricing, and the history of the costs.
How to Save Money on Lobster Per Pound
There are a few strategies that work every time to save money when purchasing lobsters.
- Always buy during lobster season as the lobsters come closer to shore, traps fill more abundantly, and there is more supply.
- Buy in bulk when purchasing lobster tails and lobster meat as most retailers have discount prices, and you can store them in your freezer for 2 to 3 months.
- To save on the price of lobster per pound, buy shucked lobster meat and not lobster tails or whole live lobsters. The shell, carapace, and insides all add to the weight you pay for.
If none of the above are an option, you can still save when buying from a store, especially when you buy live lobsters. The goal here is to reduce the amount of touchpoints between where your dinner is caught and your plate. Here’s a quick cheat sheet and some details with each to help you get the best price possible based on where you live.
| Retailer | Costs | Live Lobster (per lb) | Lobster Tail (6-8oz) | The reason for the price |
| Supermarket | Second highest price. | $16-20 | $35-45 | Highest markups as they are selling for profit, have multiple touchpoints, and holding tank costs. |
| Local Fish Market | Affordable and low cost. | $13-16 | $28-35 | There’s no preparation, only shipping and distributors. |
| Online Direct | Lowest cost and best price per pound. | $11-15 | $25-32 | Ships from the doc with no middle-touchpoints other than the retailer, only shipping expenses. |
| Restaurant | Most expensive. | $25-35 | $45-60 | Highest cost as there are shipping costs, distributors, labor costs with preparation, and a markup to turn a profit. |
For most of us, there are four ways to buy lobster no matter where you live in the USA. The grocery store, a local fish market, online directly from retailers, and at a restaurant. The prices are going to change with each, so if you don’t mind cooking or don’t feel the need to pick your own lobster out of the holding tank, you can save money.
Buying Direct Online
The least expensive option to buy lobsters is shopping with online lobster retailers that are based in Maine, Massachusetts, and other lobster fishing regions. Retailers like us specialize in lobsters and ship directly from the dock to your doorstep.
This eliminates the touchpoints of distributors, shipping to a warehouse, and excessive handling. Many (like us) are small businesses so we actually package and ship direct to you, there’s no giant processing line or holding tanks reducing your costs.
If you shop at larger online retailers that important seafood from multiple regions, chances are you’re getting a good deal, but the price per pound of lobster and other seafood may increase as there will be extra touchpoints with people buying at the dock, shipping to the seafood company’s distribution center, and then to your door.
Local Fish Markets
Your next best price for lobster is going to a local fishmarket. There are some extra touchpoints like the labor to unload trucks and pack up your fish, but they don’t overstock and store like some of the larger retailers, and they have less overhead.
Local fish markets that are located or buy direct from lobster towns tend to focus on the local dock prices and markup or down from there. A large retail chain or a supermarket could be required to go through corporate pricing at a regional or national level, and may be slower to drop prices as there is red tape compared to the local fish market that uses daily catch pricing.
Pro-tip: Try bartering prices. There’s normally bulk discounts available if you ask. If they have price breaks at 4, 8, and 12 tails, see if you can get a better one for 16 or 24 and store the extra tails in your freezer.
Supermarkets
Supermarkets have multiple distribution centers, trucking vendors, and costs with holding tanks. On top of this, national chains have to pay for corporate overhead where local chains or single locations probably have their offices and staff at a location.
Supermarkets also likely have higher margins and costs with storage, unloading trucks and boxes, staff to restock, cashiers, and other expenses that direct shippers and local fishmarkets don’t have, and this is why their costs are the third highest. With that said, they are incredibly convenient.
You likely have a supermarket closer to you than you do a fish market, and you can go right over to it and pick up lobsters if you’re craving them vs. having to wait online for a ship date and for the delivery truck to come. Yes, you can get overnight shipping, but if you want that lobster for dinner tonight, this is your best bet. And you can pick up the sides, herbs, butter, lemons, and accessories in one place. The higher prices are kind of like a convenience tax.
Restaurants
The most expensive place to get lobster per pound is a restaurant. On top of the multiple touchpoints, storage and refrigeration needs, and holding tanks if they have them on display, restaurants have to pay for:
- Labor with cooking the lobster, servers to bring it to your table, and cleaning supplies and cleaning staff for the table in between each sitting.
- There are ingredients that need purchased for cooking the lobsters that add to the price, especially if spices like saffron are part of the dish.
- Restaurant lobsters are prepared to order and only served with however many people order that night. They have to focus on margin and quality vs. selling in volume to make money like the other three options.
The price of lobster meat starts around $5.75 per pound and then goes up depending on how many touchpoints it has between the dock and your dinner plate. The more you can remove from the process, the lower your cost for lobster meat will be. And if you’re ready to get a great deal, click here and shop for your next lobster dinner with us.










