Salt Water Taffy


In stock

Assorted flavors of old-fashioned New England salt water taffy. This candy maker still uses a copper kettle over an open flame and cuts and wraps the taffy with a Model K taffy machine.

Unit price
    Pick your delivery date

    Choose from TUE to SAT*

    Order by 3 PM EST

    To get it delivered tomorrow

    Earn up to 479 Sand Dollars.

    For each of this product

    SKU: STAF Category:

    Salt water taffy supposedly originated by accident in Atlantic City, New Jersey. We have sampled taffy from Cape Cod, Nantucket, Delaware, the Jersey Shore and even Maryland .Our New England salt water taffy is made right in Massachusetts.  Our taffy is soft, chewy and bursting with over a variety of  fun flavors. Taffy is made by hand since 1946 by the Hill Top Candy Company.  It is not mass produced.

    Taffy is cooked in a copper kettle over an open flame and then cooled on tables before being rolled to make the special colors and stripes. Next the salt water taffy is stretched on an antique puller machine. Finally it is placed on the cooling table again before being placed in a Model K taffy machine to cut and wrap the taffy. There is no salt water added to the taffy!

    Bag is approximately 4 inches wide by 6 inches high. 5 ounces. Approximately 20 pieces per bag. Store your taffy in a cool dry place and it will keep for several months. Taffy is manufactured in a facility that also processes: milk, peanuts, soy and coconut. 

    Learn more about about Seaside Nostalgia and Taffy makers around the USA.

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 14 reviews
    george gilly (Madeira Beach, FL)

    Salt Water Taffy

    Nancy B. (Houston, TX)

    I was fortunate that when I purchased lobster tail meat, the salt water taffy was free. Would it be worth purchasing in the future? OH YEAH!! It was fresh, soft and chewy and FULL of flavor! Awesome stuff!

    Gerard Lavallee (Concord, NH)

    Quick and easy delivery

    Daniel Diamond (San Leandro, CA)
    Lobster Anywhere is the best.

    Best Customer Service, Quality Seafood, Fast Delivery.

    Nancy Boller (Virginia Beach, VA)
    Christmas Eve Dinner

    I ordered 4 frozen lobster tails, clam chowder for two and as a gift ,the delicious Salt WaterTaffy was included. The lobster was delivered on time and in good condition. The meat was very sweet and tender. The chowder was a little disappointing. It looked great but was bland in flavor.

    Your personal data will be used to support your experience throughout this website, to manage access to your account, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.