Captain’s Tails and Turf

From $149.00

New England never tasted so good with a classic surf and turf with fork-tender filet mignon, Atlantic lobster tails, and real good key lime pie.

Earn up to 25,900 Sand Dollars.

Order by 2 PM EST for delivery tomorrow - 8 AM EST for live lobsters. 🛫 Schedule your delivery day at checkout.

A steak and lobster gift straight from New England. Features genuine cold-water lobster tails and center-cut filet mignon.

Our North Atlantic, flash-frozen, Lobster Tails are simply the best in the world. Don’t settle for those cheap warm-water tails you find at the big club stores.

Free Lobster Shipping

For dessert cool off with a tart and tangy key lime pie made with real Key West lime juice and an authentic graham cracker crust. Yum! 

Per person:

  • (1) 8 oz. filet mignon
  • (1) 6-7 oz. cold-water lobster tail
  • (1) 1 mini key lime pie to share

Choose surf and turf dinner for 2 or 4.

Free Overnight Delivery. This special three course surf and turf ships fresh-frozen so order now and stick in your freezer.

Customer Reviews

Based on 13 reviews
Excellent birthday present for my daughter

I purchased the Captain’s Tail and Turf for my daughter’s birthday and she said it was amazing and fresh! She was pleasantly surprised to get a blueberry pie instead of the Key Lime pie and she said that was delicious warmed up (and happens to be her favorite pie). I just ordered this for my dad’s birthday, along with the clam chowder and lobster bisque

Captains Tails and Surf

The Surf and Turf package was exceptional! Instructions were included and the meal turned out wonderful. I will be using this company for all my lobster and filet mignon wants! It was yummy.


Ordered on 01/31/20 for delivery on Saturday. Received on Saturday as expected in perfect condition well frozen. The lobster and Steak were defrosted and made that night for dinner. The tails were excellent and the steak was tender and flavorful ( we used the butter). We are from the Northeast but now live in Florida and it is difficult to obtain North Atlantic lobster, so this was a special treat that exceeded our expectations. Thank you for making a birthday treat and excellent and memorable one!

Parents loved this gift!

My parents are tough to buy gifts for because they have everything they need. But they were super excited with the choices I made from Lobster Anywhere for them. Always nice to give a gift when it is a hit. Thank you for such nice selections.

Dinner for 2

I bought this last year for my son and daughter-in-law and they loved it! I am buying it again this year!

We are open. ⚓Shipping Coast-to-Coast Since 1999