Captain’s Tails and Turf

From $168.00

On sale

New England never tasted so good with a classic surf and turf with fork-tender filet mignon, cold-water Atlantic lobster tails, and real good key lime pie.

Pick your delivery date

Choose from TUE to SAT*

Order by 3 PM EST

To get it delivered tomorrow

Earn up to 33,200 Sand Dollars.

For each of this product

A steak and lobster gift straight from New England. Features genuine cold-water lobster tails and center-cut filet mignon.

Our North Atlantic, flash-frozen, Lobster Tails are simply the best in the world. Don’t settle for those cheap warm-water tails you find at the big club stores.

Free Lobster Shipping

For dessert, cool off with a tart and tangy key lime pie made with real Key West lime juice and an authentic graham cracker crust. Yum! 

Per person:

  • (1) 8 oz. filet mignon
  • (1) 6-7 oz. cold-water lobster tail
  • (1) 1 mini key lime pie to share

Choose surf and turf dinner for 2 or 4.

Free Overnight Delivery. This special three course surf and turf ships fresh-frozen so order now and stick in your freezer.

Customer Reviews

Based on 53 reviews
deandra rollings (Port Townsend, WA)

I Love You!!! you make everyone I send your beautiful seafood too sooo happy!

Jody Soper (Dallas, TX)
LobsterAnywhere Rocks!

Order lobster every year for my Dad who lives in Wisconsin! He absolutely loves it! Great choices, great and easy delivery.

Cat (Midlothian, VA)
Captains Tails and Turf

We bought this as a thank you gift. The recipients and their guests raved about the food.

CHARLES (Pittsburgh, PA)

I like to cook them on the grill. Always a treat!

Richard Kolts (Queen Creek, AZ)
Ok, But....

Delivery on time with all I ordered. But being a novice and even using their chat box, I didn't know whether to boil and grill tails before or after taking them out of the shell. Just wasn't clear. A video would have helped. More work than I expected. Filets were very very tender, but no flavor(I had heard they weren't supposed to have much, but didn't think they were this flavorless). I know restaurant lobster/steak dinners are pricey, but just as much as 2 lobster dinners and 2 8-10 oz tails with Will let someone else cook our lobsters next time. (But they are better than the other lobster providers from Maine!)

Your personal data will be used to support your experience throughout this website, to manage access to your account, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.