Sink your fork into the rich, indulgent, and tender bite of butter poached lobster tails. Butter poaching is the secret to enhancing the already sweet, rich flavor of lobster and ensure that it doesn’t over cook. This simple cooking method brings out the best in lobster every time in flavor, but additionally in texture. This method of cooking lobster enhances the natural flavors of the lobster and delivers the most incredible, delicate texture, making it great for any special meal.
By following this guide, you’ll learn how to butter poach lobster tails to get rich flavors and the perfect texture. We’ll also help you avoid common mistakes that can make lobster less tasty. Get ready to master this method and wow anyone who tries your cooking!
Why Butter Poaching Works
Page Contents
Butter poaching is a classic method of cooking everything from delicate seafood like lobster to even vegetables. Just like sous vide cooking, it is a gentle method that slowly cooks food, making it harder to overcook and become tough or dry. Butter poached lobster is done by removing the meat from the lobster and gently cooking in melted butter at a low simmer and never a boil. See our tips for cooking frozen shell-on lobster tails, providing essential guidance on how to cook lobster tails right from the freezer.
Step-by-Step Guide to Butter Poached Lobster Tails
Step 1: Preparing the Lobster Tails for Butter Poaching
Use kitchen scissors to cut along the bottom side of the lobster tails. Carefully take the meat out in one piece. Rinse it gently to clean off any bits and then pat it dry with paper towels. Taking the shell off is important to make sure the lobster absorbs the buttery flavor well.
How to make a lobster dish perfect starts with getting the meat ready the right way. By taking off the shell and cleaning it properly, you make sure the butter poached lobster turns out tender and full of flavor. You can skip this step and make this dish even more easily with the help of our shucked lobster tail meat. The work is already done for you!
Step 2: Making the Perfect Butter Bath
In a medium saucepan, heat 2–3 tablespoons of water until it’s gently simmering over low to medium heat. Slowly whisk in small cubes of cold butter, one piece at a time, letting each one melt before adding the next. Doing this slowly keeps the butter mixture (called beurre monté) smooth and stops it from separating.
Add some minced garlic and a sprig of fresh thyme or tarragon if you like for extra flavor. Keep stirring to keep the butter smooth.
To make the perfect butter poached lobster tail, it’s important to keep the butter bath smooth. Adding the butter slowly keeps it from breaking apart and makes a rich poaching liquid that cooks the lobster evenly.
Step 3: Temperature Control and Poaching
Put the lobster tails in the beurre monté. Keep the temperature between 160°F and 190°F (71°C to 87°C) by using a thermometer. This is important for keeping the lobster tender and not rubbery. Make sure the lobster temperature stays right for the best texture.
Cook lobster tail for 5–8 minutes, turning them sometimes so they cook evenly. The lobster tails are ready when the meat is opaque and the inside temperature is between 135°F and 140°F (57°C to 60°C).
Keeping the heat low and steady while poaching helps make sure the lobster doesn’t overcook. This way, the proteins in the lobster break down gently, keeping the meat soft and not tough, which can happen if you boil it too hard.
Step 4: Finish and Serve
Take the lobster tails out of the poaching liquid and lightly season them with salt. Squeeze some fresh lemon juice over the butter poached lobster to bring out its natural sweetness and balance the rich butter flavor.
Serve the lobster right away with the beurre monté drizzled over the top or as a dipping sauce. For a complete meal, you could add sides like roasted veggies or a light salad. When you’re learning how to make a lobster dish stand out, remember that small details—like fresh lemon juice and the right seasoning—make a big difference. This simple way of serving focuses on the rich, buttery taste of the chopped lobster while adding a bright, fresh touch.
Tips for Perfect Butter Poached Lobster Tails
- Always use unsalted butter so you can control the seasoning better.
- Keep a close watch on the lobster temperature to avoid overcooking. Overheating can make the meat rubbery, but the right temperature makes it juicy.
- If your butter sauce, or beurre monte, seems like it is starting to break, remove the pan from the heat and continue to stir. You can also add an ice cube if necessary while continuing to stir.
- Make sure that your butter is extremely cold. This helps with the emulsification. You can even but your butter cubes in the freezer for 30 minutes before making the sauce.
- Wondering how long do you boil lobster tails? For butter poaching, don’t actually boil them. Keep a low, gentle poach for the best results.
By following these steps, you’ll learn how to make butter poached lobster tail that is tender, full of flavor, and perfect for any special occasion.
Butter Poaching vs. Other Cooking Methods for Lobster Tails
| Cooking Method | Flavor | Tenderness | Complexity | Justification |
| Butter Poaching | Rich, buttery flavor that enhances the natural sweetness of lobster. | Very tender due to low, consistent cooking temperature. | Moderate: Requires temperature control and careful butter emulsion. | Butter poaching retains more moisture, resulting in a succulent texture. It prevents drying out, unlike grilling. |
| Steaming | Mild, retains most of the lobster’s natural flavor. | Tender, but can become slightly chewy if overcooked. | Simple: Requires minimal equipment and less oversight. | Steaming is a straightforward way to cook lobster, but it can lack the richness that butter poaching provides. |
| Grilling | Smoky, charred flavor that adds depth to the lobster. | Can become tough if not watched closely due to direct heat. | High: Requires careful monitoring to prevent overcooking. | Grilling can dry out lobster meat quickly, making it less ideal for keeping the lobster tender and juicy. |
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re looking for the perfect way to cook lobster meat to stuff our lobster roll kits, or an elegant way to cook the lobster tails included in our Back Bay Surf and Turf dinner, butter poached lobster is always an excellent option. When you start with the best Maine Grade A hardshell lobster, you want to celebrate its natural sweetness and flavor and make it completely the star. Butter poached lobster is a great way to do this while also allowing the meat to remain tender and delicate. Following this guide and the few simple steps, you are sure to have the best bite of lobster every time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is Butter Poaching?
Butter poaching is a way to cook lobster tails by gently simmering them in melted butter. This cooking method keeps the lobster tender and lets it soak up the buttery flavor, making it taste moist and delicious. It’s better than boiling or steaming if you want more flavor.
Can You Use Salted Butter to Poach Lobster Tails?
Yes, you can use salted butter to poach lobster tails, but unsalted butter is usually better because it allows you to control the seasoning more easily. Salted butter adds extra flavor. However, it can make the lobster too salty and overpower the delicate taste of the meat.
How Long Should Lobster Tails Be Poached?
Lobster tails should be poached for about 5-8 minutes. Make sure the butter temperature stays between 160-175°F to keep the lobster tender. Use a thermometer to check that the inside of the lobster reaches 135-140°F to ensure the lobster is tender without being overcooked.
Is Salted or Unsalted Butter Better for Poaching?
Unsalted butter is better for poaching lobster because it gives you more control over how much salt you add. This way, you can bring out the natural sweetness of the lobster without making it too salty. Salted butter can work too, but you have to be careful not to add extra salt.
How Do You Avoid Overcooking Lobster Tails?
To avoid overcooking lobster tails, keep the butter temperature between 160-180°F and use a thermometer to check. Cooking at a low temperature keeps the lobster tender and stops it from getting rubbery. Turn the lobster occasionally to make sure it cooks evenly.
What Makes Butter Poaching Different from Other Methods?
Butter poaching is different from other methods like boiling, steaming, or grilling because it uses gentle, even heat. This keeps the lobster moist and tender. Grilling can dry out the meat, but butter poaching makes sure the lobster stays juicy and full of rich buttery flavor. If you want soft and flavorful lobster, butter poaching is a great choice.
How Does Gordon Ramsay Poach a Lobster Tail?
Gordon Ramsay poaches lobster tails by first placing the cooked tails in ice water and then peeling them with kitchen shears. He melts butter in a small pot, adds salt, pepper, paprika, and parsley, and then simmers the lobster tails in the seasoned butter for about 1-1.5 minutes. Finally, he serves the lobster with a drizzle of butter and a squeeze of lemon juice.
What Is the Best Method of Cooking Lobster Tails?
The best method for cooking lobster tails depends on what you like. If you like a smoky flavor, grilling might be best, but for a rich flavor, butter poaching is ideal. Steaming is a good choice if you prefer a more natural taste. Steaming is quick and helps keep the natural flavor of the lobster without drying it out. Butter poaching makes the lobster rich and tender because of the buttery flavor. Grilling can give a smoky taste, but it can also make the lobster tough if you’re not careful.
What Kind of Butter Is Best for Lobster?
Clarified butter, also known as drawn butter, is the best for lobster. It is pure butterfat with the water and milk solids removed. Clarified butter won’t burn easily and has a clean, rich flavor that goes well with lobster’s sweetness, making it perfect for poaching.
How Do Chefs Cook Lobster Tails?
Chefs often cook lobster tails by slowly poaching them in butter or simmering them in seasoned water. They add herbs like thyme or parsley, along with lemon slices, to give the lobster more flavor. Cooking the lobster gently for about 5-7 minutes keeps the meat tender but firm, giving it a gourmet quality.
Butter Poached Lobster Tails Recipe
Lobster tail meat is poached in a butter bath, rendering the meat buttery and tender.
- Total Time: 15 minutes
- Yield: 6 1x
Ingredients
- 2–3 tbsp. water
- 1 cup (2 sticks) cold butter cut into 1 tbsp. pieces
- (5) 3 oz. shucked lobster tails
- Small shallow pot or a saucepan.
- Instant Read thermometer (optional)
Instructions
- In a saucepan, bring 2-3 tbs. of water to a simmer over medium heat.
- Whisk in 1 tbs. butter, when butter melts add another piece. Continuing adding butter pieces — 1 cup (two sticks total.) Do not let the butter come to a boil or the butter will separate. Try to keep the butter between 160 and 175 degrees F. Use an instant read thermometer to keep it under 180 F.
- Add defrosted, raw tails. Cook for 6-8 minutes and turn tails in butter mixture. Again, make sure the butter does not come to a boil, reduce the heat if necessary. Be careful not to overcook lobster. Poached lobster tails should have an an internal temperature of about 130-135°
Notes
Serve poached lobster tails right from the pan with fresh sliced lemons.
- Prep Time: 10
- Cook Time: 5
- Category: Entree
- Method: Poaching
- Cuisine: French
- Diet: Gluten Free
What are good sides with Butter Poached Lobster?
If you’re butter poaching some lobster tails for the family, you will want to have some delicious sides to tag on.
Baked Potatoes
Baked potatoes are a classic addition to a lobster meal, and you can even use some of that poaching butter directly on your potatoes; doesn’t that sound amazing?
Mac and Cheese
Mac and cheese is one of the heavier sides to choose for a butter poached tail, but its always a hit with the kids and probably Dad too.
Green Veggies
If you want to keep it on the healthier side, you can never go wrong with Green beans or Broccoli. A simple steam with some salt and pepper, and be sure to add some of that butter on top!
