Connecticut’s Coast of Crustacean: A Guide to the Best Lobster Rolls

This iconic sandwich, a testament to the region’s abundant seafood, has captured the hearts— and stomachs —of locals and visitors alike. Connecticut has a significant historical connection to this cherished dish, with its origins likely dating back to the 1920s, when the hot buttered version first appeared on the menu at Perry’s restaurant in Milford. This article explores Connecticut’s best lobster rolls, showcasing renowned establishments, revealing cherished local gems, and identifying the seafood shacks that deliver the flavors of Maine lobster to Connecticut.

Hot buttered Lobster rolls at Abbot's Lobsters
Lobster Rolls from Abbot’s Lobsters

The Crowd-Pleasers: Connecticut’s Best Lobster Rolls

Connecticut, a gem of New England, offers a rich tapestry of coastal experiences, and the beloved lobster roll is at the heart of its culinary scene.

Abbot’s Lobster in the Rough

Huge hot buttered lobster roll from Abbot's
Hot lobster roll with one full pound of fresh lobster meat warmed on a giant freshly baked bun.

Abbott’s Lobster in the Rough, nestled on the scenic Mystic River in Noank, stands as a true icon in Connecticut’s seafood landscape. Founded in 1947, this long-standing establishment has cultivated a loyal following for its commitment to fresh seafood and, most notably, its exceptional lobster rolls. The location, right on the water, enhances the dining experience, offering picturesque views that complement the culinary delights. Abbott’s is particularly renowned for its hot lobster rolls, prepared in the classic Connecticut style with generous portions of warm lobster meat drenched in butter. Catering to varying appetites, they offer their famous hot lobster roll in several sizes, including the substantial “OMG” roll, packed with seven ounces of lobster, and the truly indulgent “LOL” roll, featuring a full pound of the coveted crustacean. While the hot buttered version reigns supreme, Abbott’s also provides a nod to its northern neighbor with a cold New England-style lobster roll available on the menu. The enduring popularity and consistently high ratings Abbott’s has garnered over the years suggest a deep understanding and masterful execution of the quintessential Connecticut lobster roll, solidifying its position as a benchmark for enthusiasts.

Lobster Landing

Lobster roll from Lobster Landing
Hot Lobster Roll from the Lobster Landing

Further, along the coast in Clinton, Lobster Landing has carved out its own legendary status as a quintessential shoreline shack dedicated to the art of the lobster roll. This no-frills establishment focuses on a simple yet satisfying menu, with the lobster roll as the undisputed star. Their signature offering is a hot, buttered lobster roll served on an oversized, toasted Italian-style grinder roll—a unique twist on the traditional split-top bun. Often wrapped in foil, these rolls arrive at your table brimming with tender lobster meat. For those with a heartier appetite, Lobster Landing also offers a double lobster roll packed with twice the amount of this delectable seafood. The casual atmosphere is further enhanced by their BYOB policy, encouraging patrons to relax and savor their meals at their own pace. Lobster Landing frequently appears at the top of various “best of” lists, a testament to the quality and experience they provide. The description of its charmingly “wonky” building adds to its allure, painting a picture of an authentic and much-loved local institution.

Guilford Lobster Pound

Guilford Lobster Pound Lobster Rolls
Classic Connecticut hot-buttered lobster rolls at Guilford Lobster Pound.

Nestled in the charming town of Guilford, the Guilford Lobster Pound offers a unique and authentic dining experience deeply rooted in the local fishing community. Its harbor-front location, offering breathtaking views of Faulkner Island, provides a serene backdrop for a memorable meal. What truly distinguishes this establishment is its unparalleled freshness, with much of the lobster served being directly caught by the owner, Captain Bart Mansi, a local lobsterman, ensuring a quality that’s hard to beat. Their renowned hot lobster rolls, packed with generous portions of freshly picked meat, exemplify this commitment. At the same time, the locally favored clear broth clam chowder, brimming with fresh clams and lively seasonings, makes for a delightful accompaniment. Even with its popularity, the Guilford Lobster Pound maintains a slightly secluded charm, tucked away behind another restaurant, which adds to its allure for those seeking a more local feel and the promise of an incredibly fresh, authentically sourced Connecticut lobster roll straight from their pound.

Captain Scott’s Lobster Dock

Captain Scott's Lobster Dock
Captain Scott’s, New London, Connecticut.

Captain Scott’s Lobster Dock in New London provides another highly regarded option, boasting a unique location nestled between the Amtrak Acela train tracks and a marina on Shaw’s Harbor. This slightly tucked-away spot has garnered a loyal following for its delicious lobster rolls and unpretentious atmosphere. Captain Scott’s offers both hot buttered lobster rolls, prepared in the classic Connecticut style, and refreshing cold lobster salad rolls, catering to different preferences. Their generous portions and casual, no-frills ambiance contribute to its enduring popularity. Adding to its appeal, Captain Scott’s allows patrons to bring their beer or wine, fostering a relaxed and enjoyable dining experience. Despite its slightly hidden location, Captain Scott’s has earned a reputation as a must-visit destination for lobster roll enthusiasts, often described as a rewarding find.

Lenny & Joe’s Fish Tale

Hot buttered Lobster roll from Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale
Connecticut Lobster roll at the beach from Lenny & Joe’s Fish Tale.

Lenny & Joe’s Fish Tale, with locations in Westbrook and Madison, is a long-standing shoreline institution that has served the Connecticut coast since 1979. This family-friendly establishment has become synonymous with consistently delicious seafood, and their hot buttered lobster rolls are a particular highlight. Prepared simply with 100% fresh lobster meat and melted butter on a toasted split-top New England roll, their lobster rolls have become a beloved classic. Beyond their renowned lobster rolls, Lenny & Joe’s offers a wide array of other seafood delicacies, making it an excellent choice for groups with diverse palates. The longevity and multiple locations of Lenny & Joe’s suggest a commitment to quality and a consistently popular offering that keeps customers returning year after year.

Off the Beaten Path: Discovering Connecticut’s Hidden Lobster Roll Treasures

While the popular spots often draw significant attention, Connecticut’s culinary landscape is also dotted with lesser-known gems that offer exceptional lobster rolls. Locals usually cherished these rolls for their unique charm and quality. These hidden treasures provide a chance to savor this iconic sandwich away from the main tourist trails.

The Lobster Shack in East Haven

Lobster roll from the Lobster Shack
Lobster roll with onion rings at the Lobster Shack in East Haven, Connecticut.

The Lobster Shack, originally a beloved food truck, has found a permanent home and continues to serve its dedicated following. This establishment has earned a reputation among locals for its delicious, buttery, and warm lobster rolls, served on a grinder roll rather than the traditional split-top bun. Adding to its authenticity, the owners of The Lobster Shack have a genuine background in lobstering, ensuring that the lobster served is fresh and of the highest quality. This personal connection to the sea and the craft of lobstering resonates with those seeking an authentic taste of the Connecticut coast. While it might not be as widely recognized as some of the more famous spots, The Lobster Shack’s loyal customer base speaks volumes about the quality of its offering, making it a true hidden gem for lobster roll aficionados.

Ford’s Lobster

Warm Lobster Roll from Ford's Lobster in Noank, CT
Warm Connecticut Lobster Roll with French fries and cole slaw served at Ford’s Lobster in Noank, CT

While Ford’s Lobster in Noank enjoys considerable popularity, its location slightly outside the bustling downtown Mystic area and its inviting waterfront deck contribute to a less overtly “touristy” ambiance for those in the know. Beyond its scenic setting, Ford’s is celebrated for its delectable lobster rolls, available in both hot and cold preparations. However, what truly sets Ford’s apart and adds to its unique appeal is the “Lobster Bomb,” a signature dish featuring a generous portion of fresh lobster served hot with butter in a perfectly crisped bread bowl. This innovative take on the classic lobster roll, along with its slightly more secluded location, makes Ford’s a compelling choice for those seeking a memorable and perhaps less conventional experience.

Liv’s Shack

Lobster Roll Liv's Shack
Lobster Roll from Liv’s Shack, Old Saybrook.

Liv’s Shack in Old Saybrook offers a unique charm with its location nestled within the Harbor One Marina. This setting provides a delightful waterside dining experience, where patrons can enjoy their lobster rolls with views of the boats and the harbor. Liv’s Shack is particularly known for its distinctive “No Mayo” Connecticut-style hot buttered lobster rolls, catering to those who prefer the pure taste of lobster and butter. The shack’s BYOB and pet-friendly policies contribute to its relaxed and local-centric atmosphere, making it a favorite among residents seeking a casual and enjoyable meal by the water.

Knapp’s Landing

Knapp's Landing Lobster Roll
Lobster Roll with fries and coleslaw from Knapp’s Landing in Stratford, CT.

Knapp’s Landing in Stratford offers a unique hidden gem experience, with its location directly on the beachfront. Diners can enjoy their lobster rolls on a patio with stunning views of the Long Island Sound. Knapp’s Landing features a notable “King Lobster Roll,” which boasts a significantly larger portion of lobster meat compared to standard offerings. The restaurant’s no-frills ambiance and consistent positive reviews from locals solidify its reputation as a beloved spot for a satisfying seafood meal with an exceptional view.

Connecticut Seafood Shacks Serving Maine Lobster

For those who specifically seek the taste of Maine lobster, Connecticut offers several seafood shacks and restaurants that source their crustaceans from Maine, providing an authentic taste of this renowned seafood.

Lazy Lobster

The Lazy Lobster in Milford, CT
The Lazy Lobster in Milford serves up delicious lobster rolls featuring fresh lobster meat, often served on a toasted baguette.

The Lazy Lobster in Milford prides itself on serving 100% sweet, freshly shucked Maine lobster in their rolls. This commitment to using high-quality Maine lobster ensures a distinct and flavorful experience. Adding a unique touch, The Lazy Lobster serves its lobster rolls on a house-baked baguette, offering a delightful textural contrast to the tender lobster meat. This combination of premium Maine lobster and a non-traditional roll makes it a noteworthy destination for those craving a taste of the north.

LobsterCraft

LobsterCraft sells hot buttered lobster rolls.
LobsterCraft serves lobster rolls from food trucks and brick-and-mortar locations.

LobsterCraft, based in Stratford, takes its lobster sourcing seriously. This establishment is owned by a licensed lobster fisherman who catches their lobsters directly from the waters of Maine. While they are known for their award-winning hot buttered Connecticut-style rolls, their direct sourcing from Maine strongly suggests the availability of authentic Maine-style lobster rolls. Their most popular roll is the award-winning Coastal roll, which features hot, buttered lobster with a dash of their signature “Captain’s Pinch” seasoning served in a perfectly toasted bun. This is their take on the classic Connecticut-style hot buttered lobster roll and the one that started it all for them.

Westbrook Lobster Restaurant and Bar

Hot buttered roll from Westbrook Lobster Restaurant
Westbrook Lobster Connecticut-Style Lobster Roll features warm, buttered lobster meat with house seasoning on a toasted New England-style brioche roll.

Westbrook Lobster Restaurant and Bar in Clinton began as a seafood market and has evolved into a full-service restaurant that likely prioritizes high-quality seafood sourcing. While the specific origin of their lobster isn’t always explicitly stated as Maine, the reputation of Westbrook Lobster suggests a commitment to providing top-tier crustaceans, potentially sourced from the colder waters of Maine. Their transition from a market to a restaurant indicates a dedication to serving fresh and flavorful seafood, making them a reliable option for lobster lovers.

Heibeck’s Stand

Lobster roll with butter-wine sauce from Heibeck's Stand in Wilton, CT
Heibeck’s Stand serves their Lobster Roll, which features fresh Maine lobster sautéed in a homemade butter-wine sauce

Heibeck’s Stand in Wilton, a local institution that has been open since 1931, proudly serves fresh Maine lobster rolls. What makes their offering particularly unique is the preparation – the Maine lobster meat is sautéed in a distinctive house-made butter-wine sauce and served warm on a toasted New England roll. This deviation from the traditional melted butter or mayonnaise adds a layer of complexity and flavor that sets Heibeck’s Stand apart, making it a must-try for those seeking a Maine lobster roll with a special twist.

Nordic Fish

Hot and buttered lobster roll from Nordic Fish.
Nordic Fish in Fairfield, CT, offers lobster rolls with fresh, hand-picked meat.

Nordic Fish in Fairfield offers both Connecticut and Maine-style lobster rolls, either hot and butter-poached or as a cold salad, served on a buttered New England-style brioche roll. Importantly, they use fresh, hand-picked Maine lobster meat for both preparations. This dedication to using high-quality Maine lobster, regardless of the chosen style, ensures an authentic and delicious experience for those specifically seeking the taste of Maine.

Lobster Hut

Hot lobster rolls from the Lobster Hut
Lobster Hut in CT serves delicious lobster rolls, often compared to those in Cape Cod and Maine.

Finally, Lobster Hut, a popular “Seafood Trailer” in Milford, specializes in hot lobster rolls but also features a cold lobster salad roll on its menu. While the explicit origin of their lobster isn’t always mentioned as Maine, its inclusion in this section suggests that they likely source from the northern state to provide an authentic cold, mayo-based option. The casual, roadside shack vibe of Lobster Hut further enhances the experience of enjoying a classic Maine-style lobster roll.

Dive into Connecticut’s Delicious Lobster Roll Scene

Connecticut’s coastline is a veritable treasure trove for lobster roll enthusiasts. From the iconic and time-tested establishments to the charming and locally loved hidden gems and even those dedicated to bringing the taste of Maine’s prized lobster to the state, there is a perfect lobster roll waiting to be discovered by every palate. Whether your preference leans towards the traditional Connecticut hot buttered style or the refreshing Maine cold with mayo, the Nutmeg State offers a diverse and delectable array of options. Embark on your own culinary adventure, explore the various locations highlighted in this guide, and savor the exquisite taste of fresh, high-quality lobster. The journey is sure to be filled with delicious discoveries and unforgettable coastal flavors.

Appendix: Connecticut’s Best Lobster Rolls at a Glance

Restaurant/Shack NameAddressWebsite LinkDescription
Abbott’s Lobster in the Rough117 Pearl St, Noank, CT 06340abbottslobster.comA local favorite started as a food truck, serving warm, buttered lobster rolls on a grinder. The owners have a lobstering background.
Lobster Landing152 Commerce St, Clinton, CT 06413lobsterlandingct.com/Quintessential shack serving hot buttered lobster on an oversized Italian grinder roll; BYOB.
Guilford Lobster Pound505A Whitfield St, Guilford, CT 06437guilfordlobsterpound.comWaterfront Shack offers both hot and cold lobster rolls with generous portions and a no-frills atmosphere; BYOB.
Captain Scott’s Lobster Dock80 Hamilton St, New London, CT 06320captscotts.comThis Shoreline institution is famous for its simple yet delicious hot buttered lobster rolls on toasted, split-top buns; other seafood options are also available.
Lenny & Joe’s Fish TaleWestbrook: 86 Boston Post Rd; Madison: 1301 Boston Postljfishtale.comThis Shoreline institution is famous for its simple yet delicious hot buttered lobster rolls on toasted split-top buns; other seafood is also available.
The Lobster Shack3 Cosey Beach Avenue, East Haven, CT 06512lobstershackct.comThe beachfront location serves a “King Lobster Roll” with 50% more meat and a no-frills ambiance.
Ford’s Lobster15 Riverview Avenue, Noank, CT 06340fordslobster.comWaterfront dining with hot or cold lobster rolls; famous for the “Lobster Bomb.”
Knapp’s Landing520 Sniffens Lane, Stratford, CT 06615thelandingatfivetwenty.com/It catches its own lobster in Maine, serves award-winning Connecticut-style food, and likely offers Maine-style food as well.
Liv’s Shack26 Bridge Street, Old Saybrook, CTlivsshack.comThe marina location is known for “No Mayo” Connecticut-style hot buttered lobster rolls. It also offers gluten-free options, is BYOB, and is pet-friendly.
The Lazy Lobster6 Broadway, Milford, CT 06460thelazylobster.comServes 100% sweet, freshly shucked Maine lobster with butter on a house-baked baguette.
LobsterCraft1814 Post Road,
Fairfield, CT 06824		lobstercraft.comShoreline institution is famous for its simple yet delicious hot buttered lobster rolls on toasted split-top buns; other seafood is also available.
Westbrook Lobster346 E. Main St.
Clinton, CT 06413		westbrooklobster.comStarted as a market; now a restaurant likely sourcing high-quality lobster, potentially from Maine.
Heibeck’s Stand951 Danbury Road Wilton, CT 06897heibecksstand.comServes fresh Maine lobster rolls with lobster sautéed in a house-made butter-wine sauce.
Nordic FishThis Shoreline institution is famous for its simple yet delicious hot buttered lobster rolls on toasted split-top buns; other seafood is also available.“Seafood Trailer” specializes in hot lobster rolls and also offers a cold lobster salad roll.
Lobster Hut826 Bridgeport Ave, Milford, CT 06460This Shoreline institution is famous for its simple yet delicious hot buttered lobster rolls on toasted, split-top buns; other seafood options are also available.

Best Lobster Restaurants USA: A State-by-State Guide

Do you live in a landlocked state, or are you traveling to the East Coast for seafood at a local lobster shack? We’ve listed our top spots for the best lobster in the United States. Plus, we have some fun information on the history of lobster rolls and recipes for more than just hot and cold Lobster rolls.

  • Texas: Pinpoints top Texas locations for Maine lobster, from bustling cities like Houston and Dallas to coastal areas, for sourcing and savoring lobster.
  • California: Find the best places in California to enjoy Maine lobster. While finding quality lobster at a reasonable price can be tricky, there are options in both Northern and Southern California. Some restaurants and markets include Old Port Lobster Shack, Yankee Pier, King’s Fish House, and The Lobster in Santa Monica. For guaranteed Maine lobster, LobsterAnywhere.com delivers fresh lobster anywhere in the USA.
  • Ohio: Find quality lobster in landlocked Ohio by highlighting specialty seafood markets that ensure freshness through rapid delivery, live tanks, and restaurants with expert seafood preparation.
  • Minnesota: Despite being a landlocked state, Minnesota offers delicious lobster dishes and fresh Maine lobster. The article highlights restaurants like 801Fish, The Oceanaire Seafood Room, and Smack Shack in Minneapolis, as well as markets such as American Fish and Seafood and Kowalski’s, where you can find high-quality lobster.
  • Virginia: This guide on where to find the best lobster in Virginia highlights top restaurants in cities like Richmond, Virginia Beach, and Arlington. Don’t forget that LobsterAnywhere is a convenient option for fresh lobster delivery.
  • Georgia: Find the best places in Georgia to enjoy lobster, including restaurants in Atlanta, Savannah, and St. Simons Island, as well as markets for buying live lobster.
  • North Carolina: Find the best lobster in North Carolina, highlighting restaurants and seafood markets in major cities like Charlotte, Asheville, and Raleigh. Order top-notch lobster meat online and ship it to your home.
  • Pennsylvania: Find the best places to enjoy lobster in Pennsylvania, highlighting restaurants and markets in cities like Philadelphia and Pittsburgh. You can also order fresh lobster to be shipped directly to your home LobsterAnywhere.
  • New Jersey: Find the best lobster in New Jersey, covering restaurants and markets from the shore to inland cities.
  • Illinois: Despite Illinois’ landlocked location, you can find fresh Maine lobster in Illinois through reputable seafood markets that prioritize quick delivery and live tanks or by dining at restaurants known for their expertly prepared seafood dishes.
  • Florida: While Florida has its own lobster, many restaurants across the state, from the Panhandle to South Florida, serve Maine lobster. Check out some Florida restaurants that serve Maine lobster.
  • Boston, Massachusetts: This article highlights the best spots in Boston for lobster rolls, from well-known restaurants to hidden gems. They offer both classic cold and hot buttered versions. Don’t forget LobsterAnywhere’s lobster roll kits for at-home enjoyment.
  • Connecticut: Showcases top-notch lobster rolls across Connecticut, emphasizing the popular Nutmeg State preparation featuring warm, buttered lobster in a grilled split-top bun, typically skipping the mayo. Several restaurants renowned for their delicious Connecticut-style rolls are mentioned.
  • New England Lobster Shacks: Experience the quintessential New England tradition by exploring seasonal lobster shacks across Massachusetts, Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Connecticut, and Vermont, where you can savor fresh catches such as lobster, shrimp, scallops, haddock, clams, mussels, and crab in a relaxed atmosphere. This article highlights notable shacks throughout these states, emphasizing their unique offerings and the pleasure of dining on seafood with waterfront views.
  • History of Lobster Rolls: Did you know the humble lobster roll started as a simple sandwich in Connecticut back in the 1920s? This iconic New England dish journeyed up the coast and evolved into a gourmet favorite enjoyed nationwide. Want to dive deeper into the delicious lobster roll history?
  • Recipes for Lobster Rolls: Dreaming of the perfect lobster roll? This page offers more than just one way to enjoy this coastal delight, guiding you through a classic preparation and even suggesting variations for warm and cold options. Ready to explore all the delicious possibilities and learn how to make your own incredible lobster rolls? Discover the different lobster roll recipes!

References

Recipes & Comparisons:

History:

Restaurants & Reviews:

YouTube Resources

Add your comment

What are your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

A link to set a new password will be sent to your email address.

Your personal data will be used to support your experience throughout this website, to manage access to your account, and for other purposes described in our privacy policy.