When it comes to a comprehensive list of the best lobster rolls in Boston, we at LobsterAnywhere have you covered. Some cities are synonymous with a specific dish, and nothing is more Bostonian than lobster rolls. Discovering where to find Boston’s best lobster rolls is a delicious way to learn about the city and experience all that it has to offer.
Whether you’re looking for an iconic destination serving up a Maine-style cold lobster roll or a hidden gem offering a unique take on a classic, we have you covered. From the North End to the Back Bay and all the local haunts in between, this guide will help you seek out the best that Boston has to offer.
Page Contents
Map of the Best Lobster Rolls in the Boston Area
Boston Icons
We have left no shell unturned when it comes to sharing the best lobster rolls in Boston. Starting with the classics, these restaurants have been serving up succulent lobster stuffed and piled into buns and rolls. Looking for where the locals go? These are always at the top of the list.
Neptune Oyster
This North End favorite serves up both hot butter lobster rolls and classic Maine-style lobster rolls that are mayo-based on Iggy’s brioche buns. With a focus on the freshest local seafood, this small but charming gem is always busy but worth the wait.
Row 34
This stylish eatery, located in Boston’s historic Fort Point neighborhood, has been garnering rave reviews since it opened in 2013. Row 34 offers a Connecticut-style lobster roll with warm butter and Ethel’s creamy lobster roll. Come for the lobster rolls and stay for their extensive oyster list.
James Hook and Co.
This waterfront institution has been serving up fresh lobster since 1925. Not only do they offer both cold Maine-style lobster rolls and hot, buttered lobster rolls, but they also come in two sizes. Don’t forget to add a cup of lobsta bisque for dipping!
- Address: 40 Atlantic Ave, Boston, MA 02210
- Website: James Hook & Co.
The Bank’s Seafood and Steak
The Banks Seafood and Steak is a newcomer to the Back Bay. They bring sophisticated elegance to their lobster roll. Both hot and cold preparations are offered, but what sets these rolls apart are the brown butter buns, making these extra rich and indulgent. The Old Bay chips are the perfect accompaniment.
Eventide Fenway
Eventide—Fenway is an upscale counter-service seafood restaurant offshoot of the acclaimed Portland restaurant. Their menu changes daily, but the brown butter lobster roll is nutty, decadent, and beloved for a reason. Make sure to start with some oysters on the half-shell!
Hidden Gems for Lobster Rolls in Boston
From up-and-coming restaurants to tucked-away classics, Boston is alive with hidden gems that will satiate any lobster roll craving. This is where locals and seafood aficionados alike will send you.
Saltie Girl
With locations in both Boston and Los Angeles, Saltie Girl is renowned for their warm butter lobster roll with hints of Old Bay. They also serve a Maine-style cold roll. And if you stop by for lunch, you can also enjoy their lobster eggs Benedict.
Bell Isle Seafood
This family-owned market in the North End serves classics like lobster pie and does them right. They offer two varieties of lobster rolls: one with lobster meat, including the claws and knuckles, and one with all lobster tail meat.
Sullivan’s Castle Island
Enjoy your lobster roll with stunning harbor views from Sullivan’s. This casual spot is a South Boston institution known for its no-frills seafood and laid-back atmosphere.
- Address: 2080 William J Day Blvd, Boston, MA 02127
- Website: Sullivan’s
B & G Oysters
This South End favorite offers a sophisticated take on the classic lobster roll with a toasted brioche bun and a choice of hot buttered or cold with mayo. Feeling extra indulgent? B & G Oysters also offers a lobster BLT. The only thing better than lobster is lobster with bacon!
Alive & Kicking Lobsters
Located in the heart of Cambridge, this no-frills spot serves up monster lobster sandwiches piled high with fresh, lightly dressed sweet lobster meat. Unlike a more traditional lobster roll, Alive & Kicking Lobsters serves their lobster sandwich on toasted white bread. We highly recommend adding a side of their lobster bisque or clam chowder for dipping.
Lobstah on a Roll
Open in 2017, this Back Bay restaurant on Newbury Street has expanded to two locations, with the second in St. Augustine, FL. Lobstah on a Roll offers two sizes of lobster rolls, the 4-ounce Bostonian and the 6-ounce New Englander. You can get either a cold mayo New England style or a hot butter lobster roll.
Classic Boston Lobster Roll
If you are looking for a classic Boston lobster roll, it doesn’t get any more iconic than Sullivan’s Castle Island. This South Boston landmark was first opened in 1951 and has been serving up the iconic lobster roll to locals and tourists alike. Their no-frills lobster roll is all about the sweet lobster meat, lightly dressed with mayo and served on a toasted hotdog bun.
Tips for Ordering Lobster Rolls
- Hot or cold? Most restaurants serving up lobster rolls in Boston will offer two options: New England style, which is cold and dressed with mayo, and Connecticut style, which is enveloped in warm, rich butter. Both styles are equally delicious, so don’t be afraid to try both!
- Don’t be afraid to ask questions. Whether you’re unsure of hot or cold or whether you should get a larger size, your server is there to guide you.
- Enjoy the experience! From the quintessential seafood shacks to the upscale up-and-comers, enjoying a lobster roll in Boston is a full sensory experience. Savor every moment, relax, and relish each bite.
- Seek out lobster shacks! While Boston is home to many high-end, Michelin starred restaurants, New England is also known for its rustic lobster shacks. Don’t be afraid to get out of the city and enjoy a true dock to table experience.
The Best Lobster Rolls at Home
LobsterAnywhere makes it easy and convenient to relish the best lobster rolls from the comfort of your own home. Not only do we offer three different size options in our lobster roll kits, but we also include everything you need to recreate this New England favorite. From artisan sea salt butter and rich brioche buns to a sweet treat of saltwater taffy at the end of your lobster roll feast, we have you covered. Make sure to check out our easy recipe guide.
From Maine Grade A live lobsters to the ultimate surf and turf feast, LobsterAnywhere has you covered for all of your fresh seafood needs, perfect for any special occasion, big or small.