Searching for the best lobster in New Jersey can feel like trying to find buried treasure. Finding succulent, high-quality lobster can be daunting when navigating a sea of inconsistent reviews, fluctuating prices, and questions about freshness.
Stress no more! Your quest ends here.
We’ve created a treasure map that takes you straight to the treasure you’re looking for. Dive into our guide to find out where to buy the best lobster in New Jersey.
Where to Buy Lobster in New Jersey
Page Contents
Best Seafood Restaurants in New Jersey Selling Lobster
Chart House (Weehawken)
Chart House serves a savory Lobster Francaise inside a swanky, upscale dining room featuring stunning views of the Manhattan skyline. The dish features tender lobster meat lightly breaded and sauteed in a rich lemon-butter sauce. Prices for this range from $45-55. Located on the Hudson River in Weehawken, NJ, this is a seafood restaurant you don’t want to miss out on!
The Lobster House (Cape May)
The Lobster House is home to some of the best seafood in Jersey. Their Steamed Lobster is a classic favorite, and the restaurant’s nautical setting includes a dockside dining area and a seafood market. Whole steamed lobsters are priced by weight but stay in the $30-$60 range. You can visit The Lobster House in Cape May, New Jersey.
Dock’s Oyster House (Atlantic City)
Dock’s Oyster House was established in 1897, and it’s a historic restaurant known for its high-quality seafood. Their Lobster Tail dish is served with drawn butter and your choice of yummy sides. Guests describe the dining experience as luxurious and flavorful. You can buy a lobster tail for around $40-$65 in Atlantic City at Dock’s.
Kleins Fish Market and Waterside Cafe
This fifth generation family run Jersey shore establishment doubles as an open air fishmarket and cafe. It is celebrating 95 years of dishing out fresh lobster and seafood. They serve steamed lobsters in sizes 1-1¼ lb, 1½ lb, 2 lb lobsters delivered daily. Also offers a fresh sweet lobster salad tossed in homemade dressing, served on a buttered New England roll.
The Lobster Shanty NJ
Looking for a savory lobster dish? Then The Lobster Shanty NJ might have what you’re looking for. Their guest favorite is Lobster Bisque. Creamy and rich, with chunks of hearty lobster meat, you’ll be glad you made the drive. Their savory soup is priced around $15-$20. The Lobster Shanty’s warm, inviting dining atmosphere serves fresh seafood and bisque.
Ship Bottom Shellfish, New Jersey
This seafood spot opened in 1986 starting out as a clam purveryor. Ship Bottom, NJ is referred to as the “Gateway to Long Beach Island” with 1.36 miles of ocean frontage. Eat in or take out at the fresh fish market. BYOB. They offer grilled lobster tails and live lobster at market price. For starters try the buffalo calamari with blue cheese dressing or a bucket steamed Ipswich clams served with their broth and drawn butter.
Best Lobster Roll in New Jersey
Point Lobster Co (Point Pleasant Beach)
One of New Jersey’s best lobster rolls is found at Point Lobster Co in Point Pleasant Beach. Operating as a seafood market and takeout spot, this local favorite is beloved for its generously filled Lobster Rolls. Meticulously put together with succulent lobster meat and served on a perfectly toasted bun, it’s a must-try for any lobster lover. These Lobster Rolls are priced around $22-$30; you can find them in Point Pleasant Beach, NJ.
Jack Baker’s Wharfside (Point Pleasant Beach)
Jack’s Lobster Roll is to die for. It offers a full-flavored Lobster Roll with generous portions of fresh lobster meat. Lightly dressed with a hint of mayonnaise, served in a buttery toasted bun. The roll is then garnished with crisp lettuce and a sprinkle of fresh herbs, enhancing the lobster’s natural sweetness and flavor. Enjoy this delectable dish while soaking up the scenic views of the marina for a picturesque seafood dining experience in Point Pleasant Beach, NJ. Lobster Rolls are priced from $22-$30.
Surf City Bar Jersey City
Surf City Bar surprisingly has one of the best Lobster Rolls in New Jersey. Their laid-back beachside atmosphere makes them an immediate winner for people who want to buy the best lobster in New Jersey, but their dish makes them an absolute must-try. Their Lobster Roll is made with fresh lobster meat, lightly dressed, and served on a buttery toasted bun. Prices are from $20-$30
Caldwell Seafood (Caldwell, NJ)
Caldwell Seafood in Caldwell, NJ, has two delicious Lobster Rolls. They feature a Maine Lobster Roll, served cold with fresh lobster meat and celery in a mayo dressing and a buttery toasted bun. They also offer a New England Lobster Roll served warm with drawn butter and coleslaw. Both lobster rolls are priced around $25-$30 each.
The World’s Best Place to Buy Lobster Is…
Lobster Anywhere is the best place to buy lobster in New Jersey or anywhere else. We sell only the freshest lobster meat and ship it directly to your doorstep. Whether you want live lobster, lobster tails, or even lobster rolls, we have high-quality, fresh, and carefully sourced lobster meat.
With free overnight shipping available, our lobster also makes the perfect gift for someone special.
Check out our selection of lobsters or purchase a gift certificate for your loved one.