Give unforgettable Maine lobster Christmas gifts in 2025 with nationwide Christmas lobster delivery. Since 1999, LobsterAnywhere has shipped live lobster, jumbo lobster tails, seafood gift boxes, surf & turf dinners, and instant digital gift certificates with guaranteed freshness and free express delivery on qualifying orders.
Perfect for: Christmas dinner celebrations, romantic dinners for two, family feasts, and corporate gifting.
CRITICAL DEADLINE: Order by Tuesday, December 16, 2025, for guaranteed Christmas delivery
Not sure which Maine lobster Christmas gift to send? Use this 30-second guide.
| Budget under $150? | → Lobster Tails Christmas Special (4–24 tails) |
| Steak lover? | → Back Bay Surf & Turf – Steak & Lobster Dinner |
| Want to impress? | → Monster Giant Lobster Tails (16–28 oz) |
| Lobster rolls for a crowd (4–16)? | → Maine Lobster Roll Party Kits |
| After Dec 16 or unsure? | → Instant Digital Lobster Gift Certificate |
This comprehensive guide features best-selling lobster Christmas gifts, including pricing, 2025 holiday delivery timing, and order-by dates, as well as expert cold-chain handling tips, corporate gifting solutions, and answers to your most frequently asked holiday questions.
Critical Order-By Guidance for Christmas 2025
Christmas Day 2025 is Thursday, December 25
Recommended delivery date: Tuesday, December 16, 2025 (or earlier)
This creates a 72-hour safety buffer against peak season delays and winter weather—your best protection for stress-free holiday planning.
Why we don’t recommend Christmas Eve delivery: Peak holiday shipping volumes and potential weather delays make December 24 risky. We never want to disappoint you during the most important meal of the year.
💡 Pro Tip: Use our Date Picker at checkout to schedule delivery for any day that works for you. Order now, relax later—one less thing to worry about during the busiest season.
Best Maine Lobster Christmas Gifts 2025 (Editor’s Top Picks)
All packages include Free Express Delivery on qualifying orders. Prices reflect November 2025 market rates and are subject to change based on availability.
Best Sellers & Holiday Favorites
#1 Best Seller: Lobster Tails Special (6-7 oz)
Our most popular Christmas gift. These generous 6-7 oz cold-water tails (equivalent to a 1½ lb live lobster) arrive frozen and packed with sweet, tender meat. Perfect for an unforgettable holiday feast or as a luxury gift that ships straight to their door.
Starting at $149.95 for four tails | Free Express Delivery Shop Lobster Tails →
Fresh Shucked Lobster Tail Meat
Zero prep work required. Pure tail meat completely removed from the shell—approximately five whole shucked tails (3-4 oz each) per pound. Perfect for butter-poaching, elegant pasta dishes, or sophisticated medallions. Ships frozen for flexible timing.
Starting at $129 for a five-pack | Free Delivery Shop Shucked Lobster Tails →
Colossal All-Natural Shrimp
Premium black tiger prawns naturally raised in Vietnam’s mangrove forests—zero feed, chemicals, or antibiotics. Choose Colossal (16-20 count/lb) or Super Colossal (8-12 count/lb). IQF, peeled, and deveined in convenient 1-pound resealable bags.
Showstopper idea: Create an impressive Shrimp Christmas Tree centerpiece in just 35 minutes!
Certified sustainable | Starting at $29/lb Shop Colossal Shrimp →
Maine Lobster Ravioli
Handcrafted locally with sweet Maine lobster meat, ricotta & mozzarella in fresh pasta (10-12 large ravioli per pound). Pairs beautifully with garlic butter, cream sauce, or pink vodka sauce. Ships frozen.
Starting at $36/lb Shop Lobster Ravioli →
Giant Lobster Tails (16-28 oz) — Ultimate Centerpieces
Make a dramatic holiday statement with colossal Atlantic lobster tails from the deep, cold North Atlantic. These trophy tails deliver superior sweetness and tenderness compared to warm-water varieties. LIMITED SUPPLY—these spectacular sizes sell out quickly during holidays!
- Whale of a Tail (16-20 oz) — Available in 2, 4, 8, and 12 packs. Starting at $189 | FREE Express Shipping Shop Whale Tails →
- MONSTER Lobster Tails (20-24 oz) — Uniquely processed for extra tenderness. Starting at $229 | FREE Overnight Delivery Shop Monster Tails →
- MOBY Super-Colossal (25-28 oz) — Named after Moby Dick. Trophy-size centerpieces bigger than your arm! EXTREMELY LIMITED—reserve early! Starting at $239 | FREE Overnight Delivery Shop Moby Tails →
Pro Tip: Giant tails are NOT tough when cooked properly—the secret is avoiding overcooking. See our detailed lobster tail cooking guide for exact times & temperatures.
For Romantic Dinners & Couples
You’re My Lobster
For the lobster lover on your list—or your special someone.
Inspired by the iconic Friends episode, this playful package delivers one lb. of cooked Maine lobster meat, 16 oz. of rich lobster bisque, and a milk chocolate lobster filled with caramel, pecans, and buttercrunch toffee.
Perfect for making four overflowing lobster rolls or creating an indulgent lobster stew. A fun, delicious way to celebrate couples, anniversaries, or anyone who deserves a little lobster love this holiday season.
$149 Ships free | Great for one or two people Shop Lobster Lovers Gift →
For Family Gatherings & Seafood Lovers
Maine Fresh Catch Dinner
Festive seafood spread featuring Maine lobster tails, colossal shrimp (16-20 count), jumbo sea scallops, and classic whoopie pies. Ships fresh-frozen for flexible timing. Available for 2 or 4 people.
$189 Ships free | Maine Fresh Catch →
Down East Seafood Feast
Authentic New England Christmas feast includes: (2) 6-7 oz Maine lobster tails, 1 lb local sea scallops, award-winning New England clam chowder (serves 2), and wild Maine blueberry pie. Complete Down East experience in one package.
$189 Ships free | Shop Down East Dinner →
Maine Lobster Rolls
Bring a taste of Maine to your holiday gatherings.
Perfect for casual holiday parties, Christmas Eve get-togethers, or New Year’s celebrations. Our DIY kits include premium tail, claw, and knuckle meat, locally baked brioche rolls, Maine sea salt butter, and complete instructions. Make them classic with mayo or warm Connecticut-style. Kits serve 4-16 people.
At about $22-23 per roll delivered, it beats any lobster shack—and there’s no waiting in line. Ships free.
Starting at $144.95 for a half kit | Free Express Delivery Shop Lobster Roll Kits →
The Ultimate Holiday Gifts for Steak & Seafood Lovers
Give an unforgettable five-star dinner this Christmas with our Back Bay Surf & Turf—better than what you’ll find at most steakhouses or online meat purveyors. This exceptional gift includes center-cut filet mignons (a full 1.5 inches thick), jumbo cold-water lobster tails, and Boston’s best New England clam chowder.
Unlike catalog companies that use cheap warm-water substitutes, we source only authentic North Atlantic lobster tails. Ready in under 20 minutes from grill to table. Ships frozen with FREE overnight delivery. Available for 2 or 4 people.
Starting at $209 | Free Delivery Shop Back Buy Surf + Turf →
Make Christmas dinner unforgettable—without the holiday stress.
Our Lazy Man Lobster Dinner pairs freshly shucked Maine lobster tails with fork-tender 8-oz. filet mignons. No shells, no crackers needed—just restaurant-quality surf and turf in minutes. Steam the lobster for 4-5 minutes and you’ve got a showstopping Christmas meal.
Each dinner includes 2-3 premium lobster tails and one filet mignon per person, plus Maine sea salt butter. Ships free with guaranteed delivery.
Starting at $184.95 | Free Delivery Shop Lazy Man Lobster →
Perfect for Christmas Eve or Christmas Day celebrations.
For Flexibility & Convenience
Fresh Shucked Tail Meat
Give fresh Maine lobster tail meat—already shucked and ready to cook. No shells, no crackers, no mess. Each one-pound package includes five whole cold-water lobster tails, completely de-shelled using high-pressure processing.
Perfect for butter-poaching, pan-searing, or impressive surf & turf dinners. Ships frozen for flexible timing—100% usable meat with none of the work.
Starting at $129 for five five-pack | Free Delivery Shop Naked Tails →
Digital Gift Certificate (Instant Delivery)
Perfect last-minute solution! The recipient chooses their preferred date, package type, and serving size. No shipping deadlines, no concerns about freshness. Email delivery in minutes. Available in any amount.
Starting at $50 Buy E-card→
Live Lobster vs. Tails vs. Picked Meat — Which Should You Send?
| Product Type | Best For | Prep Level | Storage | Starting Price |
| Live Maine Lobster | Traditionalists who love the authentic experience | Moderate | Cook within 24-48 hours | ~$34 per 1.5 lb |
| Lobster Tails (in shell) | Convenience seekers who want flexibility | Easy | Freeze up to 6 months | $22-35 per tail |
| Picked Lobster Meat | Recipe enthusiasts making rolls, pasta, and bisque | Minimal | Refrigerate or freeze | $79 per lb |
Quick Decision Guide
- Choose Live Lobster if: Lobster lovers appreciate traditional New England experiences and will cook immediately.
- Choose Tails if: They want flexibility, love surf & turf, or need to freeze for later.
- Choose Picked Meat if: They’re making lobster rolls, pasta, or want zero prep work.
- Not sure? Send a digital gift certificate and let them choose!
Picked Lobster Meat — Ultra Convenience
- Best for: Recipe enthusiasts creating lobster rolls, pasta, risotto, bisque, or salads
- 100% pure lobster meat—no shells, no waste, no mess
- Ships fresh or frozen, depending on the product; refrigerate immediately or freeze for later use
Starting at $79 per lb Buy Cooked Lobster Meat →
Holiday Delivery Excellence: 26 Years of Cold-Chain Expertise
Since 1999, we’ve perfected specialized cold-chain logistics for delivering premium seafood during the challenging holiday season.
What Makes Our Delivery Different
- Custom insulated packaging maintains optimal temperatures throughout transit.
- Frozen gel packs keep live lobsters at a precise 31-32°F (never dry ice—it’s lethal to live lobsters)
- Express transit: typically 24-30 hours maximum shipping time
- FREE Express Delivery included on qualifying holiday packages
- Protective seaweed bedding for natural insulation and moisture control
What To Do When Your Lobster Arrives
TIME-SENSITIVE: Follow these steps asap.
- Open the packaging immediately. Verify that the contents feel cold and that the gel packs are still frozen or very cold.
- Live lobsters: Keep in original packaging in refrigerator (never in fresh water, never frozen). Cook within 24-48 hours.
- Tails & meat: Refrigerate if cooking within 1-2 days, or freeze at -10°F or below for up to 6 months.
- Concerned about temperature or delays? Contact our support team immediately with your order number.
Need more help? See our live lobster storage guide and complete cooking guide.
Perfect Complements for Your Christmas Lobster Feast
New England Classics
- New England Clam Chowder — Creamy, authentic, loaded with clams
- Lobster Bisque — Rich, velvety, restaurant-quality soup
Essential Accompaniments
- Drawn butter or brown-butter lemon sauce (see our best lobster sauces guide)
- Fresh lemon wedges and parsley
- Garlic bread or crusty sourdough
- Simple green salad or roasted seasonal vegetables
- Crisp white wine, champagne, or craft beer (see our wine and lobster pairing guide)
Real reviews from 26 years of delivering Christmas joy.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ John B., Van Nuys, CA
“They arrived on time and were still frozen here in Los Angeles. Grilled and absolutely delicious—my dad was thrilled on Christmas Eve.” Product: Tails Special
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Mary T., Indianapolis, IN
“Ordered the Lobster Tails special for friends. Arrived as scheduled, thawed beautifully, and the cooking instructions were spot on.” Product: Holiday Dinner
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Gayle S., Denver, CO
“Perfect Christmas gift—everybody loves them.” Product: Gift Delivery
Lobster Christmas Gifting FAQs
When should I order Maine lobster for Christmas 2025?
For a Christmas Day meal (Thursday, December 25, 2025), target delivery by Thursday, December 18, 2025, or earlier. This creates a 72-hour safety buffer against peak season shipping delays and winter weather. The earlier you order, the better your odds of perfect timing.
Is live lobster shipping safe during winter?
Yes. We maintain a strict cold-chain process with specialized insulated packaging and frozen gel packs (never dry ice for live lobsters). Our Express transit windows and 26 years of experience ensure safe delivery even during harsh winter conditions. However, we always recommend ordering early to build in extra time.
What happens if the carrier is delayed?
Peak holiday volume and winter weather can occasionally affect air cargo hubs and delivery networks. This is precisely why we recommend ordering with a 72-hour buffer. If unexpected delays occur, contact our support team immediately. Our packaging is designed to maintain temperatures for extended periods, but early ordering is your best protection.
How should I store lobster after it arrives?
Open the box immediately upon arrival. Verify gel packs are cold. Live lobsters stay in their packaging in the refrigerator (never in fresh water, never frozen). Cook within 24-48 hours. Lobster tails and meat can be refrigerated for immediate use or frozen at -10°F or below for up to 6 months. See our live lobster storage guide.
What if I need a last-minute Christmas gift?
Purchase a LobsterAnywhere digital gift certificate for instant email delivery. No shipping deadlines, no freshness concerns, no stress. Recipients choose their preferred date, package type, and serving size. Available in any amount starting at $50.
What’s better for gifting—live lobsters or lobster tails?
It depends on your recipient. Live lobsters offer the traditional experience and ultimate freshness, but require cooking within 24-48 hours. Lobster tails are more flexible—they can be frozen for months, are easier to prepare, and work perfectly in surf & turf dinners. For uncertain schedules, gift certificates are a safer choice.
Do you ship to all 50 states?
Yes. LobsterAnywhere delivers premium Maine lobster gifts to all 50 states. Rural and remote areas may require additional transit time, so early ordering is especially important for these destinations.
Can I schedule delivery for a specific date?
Yes! Select your preferred delivery date (Tuesday-Saturday) during checkout. For Christmas, we recommend choosing arrival before December 16, 2025 to avoid potential holiday shipping delays.
What if the recipient isn’t home when the lobster arrives?
Most carriers will leave the package at the door. Our insulated packaging maintains proper temperatures for several hours, but the package should be retrieved and refrigerated as soon as possible. We recommend alerting the recipient about their expected delivery date.
Do you offer gift wrapping or messages?
Every package is packed with our classic Maine vintage paper topping for a gift-ready presentation. You can add a personalized message during checkout that we’ll include with the shipment.